Complex Immigration Matters

A consultation in progress at the Pacific Ways Immigration Consultancy office in Surrey, British Columbia

Complex Immigration Matters

When your status in Canada is at risk, you need clear guidance and strong representation. Complex immigration matters require experience, strategy, and an understanding of how IRCC, CBSA, and the Immigration and Refugee Board make decisions.

Most immigration work is an application. This is the other kind: the file where a decision has already gone against you, or is about to, and the next step is a hearing, an appeal, or a written answer with a deadline on it.

Gurpreet Oshan is a Regulated Canadian Immigration Consultant with the IRB specialization (RCIC‑IRB), which authorizes representation before the Immigration Division and the Immigration Appeal Division of the Immigration and Refugee Board, as well as the preparation of submissions to IRCC and the CBSA.

This page sets out the areas Pacific Ways takes on in this field, what the decision‑maker in each one is actually deciding, and the deadlines that govern them.

Who decides what

These matters move between four decision‑makers, and they do not do the same job. Knowing which one is in front of you determines what argument is worth making.

An IRCC officer
Decides applications, and can refuse one. An officer may also issue a procedural fairness letter before refusing, or call you to an interview. An officer has discretion, which is why how a concern is answered matters.
The CBSA
Enforcement. Writes inadmissibility reports, detains, refers cases to the Immigration Division and carries out removals. The CBSA is a party at your hearing, not the decision‑maker.
The Immigration Division (ID)
An independent tribunal. Holds admissibility hearings and detention reviews. It decides whether the allegation is made out — and almost nothing else. It has no power to forgive a case on compassionate grounds.
The Immigration Appeal Division (IAD)
An independent tribunal, and the place where discretion returns. It can allow an appeal because a decision was wrong, because the process was unfair, or because humanitarian and compassionate considerations justify relief.

Admissibility hearings and detention reviews

Representation at the Immigration Division, where inadmissibility is decided and removal orders are made.

A case reaches the Immigration Division when an officer writes a report alleging that a permanent resident or foreign national is inadmissible, and that report is referred for a hearing. The ID then decides whether the alleged inadmissibility is established. If it is, the ID makes the applicable removal order. If it is not, the proceedings before the ID conclude — although the Minister has a right of appeal from an ID decision at an admissibility hearing (s. 63(5)).

Not every allegation goes to a hearing. Under s. 44(2) and R228, a report raising only certain grounds is not referred to the Immigration Division at all: an officer issues the removal order directly. Whether you get a hearing is itself a question worth checking early.

What brings a case to the ID

  • Misrepresentation — directly or indirectly withholding or misstating material facts (s. 40)
  • Serious criminality and criminality — convictions in Canada or abroad (s. 36)
  • Security, human or international rights violations, organized criminality (ss. 34, 35, 37)
  • Failure to comply with the Act — working or studying without authorization, overstaying, breaching conditions (s. 41)
  • Residency obligation breaches by permanent residents (s. 28)

The detention review clock

In most cases the ID must review the reasons for detention within 48 hours of detention, or without delay afterward, again within the following seven days, and then at least once during each 30‑day period (s. 57). Different rules apply to designated foreign nationals under s. 57.1.

Each review is a fresh decision. An earlier decision to detain does not settle the next one, and a release plan that was not ready in week one can succeed in week three.

A point worth noting

The Immigration Division is not weighing your life in Canada. It is deciding a narrow question of fact and law: is this person inadmissible on the ground alleged? Sympathy, establishment, family, hardship — none of it gives the ID a reason to decide otherwise, because it has no discretion to exercise.

That is why the work at this stage is evidentiary and legal. The compassionate case is made later, at the IAD or through a separate application — and keeping that door open is often decided by what happens at the ID hearing.

What Pacific Ways does at this stage

  • Reviews the officer’s report and the CBSA’s disclosure
  • Identifies whether the allegation is actually made out on the evidence
  • Prepares documentary evidence and witnesses
  • Makes legal submissions on the inadmissibility ground
  • Builds and presents release plans at detention reviews
  • Protects the appeal position for what comes next

Appeals to the Immigration Appeal Division

Refused sponsorships, removal orders and residency obligation decisions — and the one forum where compassionate circumstances can carry a case on their own.

Three kinds of appeal are commonly brought by clients. A sponsor whose family class application was refused may appeal that refusal. A permanent resident or protected person issued a removal order may appeal the order. A permanent resident found outside Canada not to have met the residency obligation may appeal that decision. These are not the only appeals the IAD hears — the Minister can also appeal an Immigration Division decision under s. 63(5).

What the IAD can do

Under s. 67(1), the IAD may allow an appeal if the decision was wrong in law or fact, if a principle of natural justice was not observed, or if sufficient humanitarian and compassionate considerations warrant special relief, taking into account the best interests of any child directly affected.

Under s. 68, it can also stay a removal order on the same compassionate grounds, on conditions, and reconsider the appeal later.

When there is no appeal

Section 64 removes the right of appeal where the person was found inadmissible for security, violating human or international rights, sanctions, serious criminality or organized criminality. For this purpose serious criminality means a crime punished in Canada by six months’ imprisonment or more, or an offence or act outside Canada falling under s. 36(1)(b) or (c) — so a foreign conviction can bar an appeal with no Canadian sentence at all.

A sponsorship refusal based on misrepresentation also cannot be appealed — unless the person refused is the sponsor’s spouse, common‑law partner or child, which is exactly the situation most of our clients are in.

A stay is not the end of the matter

If the IAD stays a removal order, it imposes conditions and keeps the file. It can cancel the stay at any time. And where the stay was granted to someone found inadmissible for serious criminality, criminality or transborder criminality, a further conviction for an offence described in s. 36(1) cancels the stay by operation of law and terminates the appeal (s. 68(4)) — no hearing, no discretion.

Clients living under a stay need to understand this on day one, not after the fact.

What Pacific Ways does at this stage

  • Confirms the appeal right exists before anything is filed
  • Files the notice of appeal within the time limit
  • Reviews the appeal record and the reasons for refusal
  • Prepares affidavits, witness evidence and country documentation
  • Prepares for and attends ADR conferences
  • Represents you at the IAD hearing

Where s. 64 bars an appeal, the remaining route is an application for leave and judicial review in the Federal Court — filed within 15 days for a matter arising in Canada, or 60 days for a matter arising outside Canada. Federal Court litigation must be conducted by a lawyer, not a consultant. We will tell you plainly when that is the position you are in, and when the clock started.

Procedural fairness letters

A chance to answer a concern before it becomes a refusal — and, where misrepresentation is alleged, before it becomes a five‑year bar.

A procedural fairness letter is an officer telling you, in writing, that they have a concern serious enough to refuse your application, and giving you a chance to respond first. It is not a formality. It is usually the point at which the outcome is still movable. Not every refusal is preceded by one, and an officer may also ask for further evidence in other ways.

What triggers one

  • Suspected misrepresentation or inconsistent information
  • Doubts about the genuineness of a relationship
  • Unauthorised work or study, or breach of conditions
  • Financial documents the officer does not accept
  • Travel history inconsistent with what was declared
  • Residency obligation shortfalls
  • Criminal or medical admissibility concerns

Why misrepresentation is different

If a misrepresentation finding is actually made, it is not simply a refusal. It makes the person inadmissible for five years, and they cannot apply for permanent residence during that period. A letter alleging misrepresentation is not yet a finding — which is precisely why the response matters.

The five years run from the final determination if the decision was made outside Canada, or from the day the removal order is enforced if it was made in Canada — which means the clock may not start when it first appears to.

Answer the concern the officer actually raised

The common failure is a response that explains the applicant’s good character and general intentions without ever addressing the specific discrepancy on the file. An officer reading that is left with the concern intact.

A response that works identifies precisely what the officer is looking at, explains it with documents rather than assertions, corrects the record where something was genuinely wrong, and deals with the materiality of the point. Take the deadline in the letter seriously. Where you need more time, ask for an extension before the deadline, with reasons. An extension is not automatic.

What Pacific Ways does at this stage

  • Identifies the precise concern and the provision behind it
  • Assembles the documentary record that answers it
  • Drafts submissions addressing materiality and intent
  • Applies the relevant policy and case law
  • Files within the deadline, or requests an extension where more time is justified

IRCC and CBSA interview preparation

An interview is evidence. What is said in it is compared, line by line, with what is already on the file.

Officers call interviews when something needs clarification or when a concern has already formed. Interviews are scheduled in spousal sponsorship files, misrepresentation inquiries, study and work permit matters, residency obligation reviews, and at the border by the CBSA.

What actually goes wrong in interviews

Dishonesty is rarely the problem. The problem is inconsistency — a date remembered differently, an address given loosely, an answer that contradicts a form filled out two years earlier by someone else. Honest people produce these contradictions under pressure, and an officer is entitled to draw conclusions from them.

Preparation is not rehearsing answers. It is understanding what was previously declared, identifying any discrepancies before the officer does, and being able to explain the facts accurately and consistently. Where something on the file is wrong, the approach is to correct it and explain it.

What Pacific Ways does at this stage

  • Full review of your immigration history and every form filed
  • Identifies the inconsistencies an officer will find
  • Mock interviews under realistic conditions
  • Prepares you for the questions the concern on file invites
  • Attends where attendance is permitted

Authorization to Return to Canada

If a removal order was enforced against you, returning is not simply a matter of applying for a new visa.

Section 52(1) prevents a foreign national from returning to Canada after a removal order has been enforced unless an officer authorizes it, or unless the regulations exempt them. Which situation you are in depends entirely on the type of order that was issued.

Type of removal orderIs an ARC required to return?
Departure order, properly complied with Generally no. If you left within 30 days of the order becoming enforceable and confirmed your departure, no authorization is needed.
Departure order, not complied with It becomes a deportation order once the 30 days run out — and then an ARC is required. The 30‑day clock is suspended while you are detained or while removal is stayed (R224(3)).
Exclusion order Yes, for one year after the order was enforced, as a general rule. A narrow exemption applies under R225(4).
Exclusion order following a misrepresentation finding Yes, for five years after the order was enforced.
Deportation order Yes, at any time after the order was enforced. This requirement does not expire.

An ARC is not a visa, and it is not rehabilitation

Authorization to return deals only with the removal order. It does not cure any other ground of inadmissibility. If criminality is also in play, the route depends on the offence and where it happened: deemed rehabilitation may apply automatically, individual rehabilitation is generally available five years after the sentence is completed for qualifying foreign convictions, a Canadian conviction may instead call for a record suspension, and a temporary resident permit under s. 24 is a separate option again. And you will still need the visa or eTA appropriate to your purpose.

People are refused because they applied for one of these and not the others. The sequence matters, and it should be worked out before anything is filed.

What Pacific Ways does at this stage

  • Establishes which order was issued and when it was enforced
  • Confirms whether an ARC is required at all
  • Explains the circumstances of the removal candidly
  • Documents compliance, rehabilitation and changed circumstances
  • Sets out the reasons for return and the ties supporting it
  • Coordinates the ARC with any rehabilitation, TRP or visa application

Humanitarian and compassionate applications

Section 25 of the Act — a request for discretion where the ordinary rules would produce an unjust result.

An H&C application asks the Minister to grant permanent residence, or to exempt an applicant from a requirement of the Act, because humanitarian and compassionate considerations justify it — taking into account the best interests of any child directly affected. It is not a program with criteria. It is a request for discretion, and it succeeds or fails on how the circumstances are presented.

What carries weight

  • Establishment in Canada — time here, work, taxes, housing, community ties
  • Family relationships and the effect of separation
  • The best interests of children directly affected, which must be identified and weighed
  • Hardship on return — conditions in the country, health care available, ability to re‑establish
  • Health and medical circumstances

Who cannot apply

  • Anyone inadmissible under ss. 34, 35, 35.1 or 37 — security, human or international rights violations, organized criminality
  • Anyone with an H&C request already pending. Only one at a time
  • Anyone with a refugee claim pending before the RPD or RAD
  • Anyone whose refugee claim was rejected, withdrawn after evidence was heard, or abandoned less than 12 months ago. When that year starts depends on what happened at the RPD, the RAD and the Federal Court
  • Anyone with a pending application for protection after a claim was found ineligible for the RPD
  • Designated foreign nationals, who face a separate five‑year restriction (s. 25(1.01))

The distinction that decides these applications

An H&C application is not a substitute for a refugee claim. Section 25(1.3) prevents an officer from deciding it by applying the refugee tests in s. 96 and s. 97. The same officer must still consider the hardship your circumstances would cause you, including relevant country conditions.

This is a difference in the legal question being asked, not merely in vocabulary. Relabelling a refugee narrative as hardship does not work; the evidence has to be marshalled for the distinct H&C assessment, and tied to you rather than to a general situation. An application that simply reads as a refugee claim invites a refusal.

The 12‑month bar after a negative refugee decision also has two exceptions: where removal would expose the applicant to a risk to life because their country cannot provide adequate health or medical care, and where removal would adversely affect the best interests of a child directly affected.

What Pacific Ways does at this stage

  • Confirms eligibility and whether any bar applies
  • Builds the establishment record with documents, not assertions
  • Prepares a best‑interests‑of‑the‑child analysis that is specific to the children involved
  • Translates country conditions into hardship, not risk
  • Drafts the submissions and assembles the supporting evidence
  • Responds to any request for further information or interview

Deadlines at a glance

These are the time limits that end cases. They are short, and most of them run from the day you receive a decision, not the day it was made.

StepTime limit
First detention reviewWithin 48 hours of being taken into detention, or without delay afterward
Second detention reviewWithin 7 days of the first
Subsequent detention reviewsAt least once during each 30‑day period. Designated foreign nationals are reviewed on a different schedule
IAD appeal — refused sponsorship30 days after receiving the refusal letter and any written reasons
IAD appeal — removal order30 days after receiving the removal order, or filed at the end of the admissibility hearing
IAD appeal — residency obligation60 days after receiving the officer’s decision and reasons
Procedural fairness letter responseAs stated in the letter — often 7 to 30 days, but there is no fixed statutory range. Ask for any extension before it expires
Departure order compliance30 days from the day the order becomes enforceable, or it becomes a deportation order. The clock is suspended during detention or a stay
Judicial review — matter arising in Canada15 days after being notified of the decision
Judicial review — matter arising outside Canada60 days after being notified of the decision

Tribunals can extend some of these time limits, and the Federal Court may allow an extension for special reasons. None of that is something to rely on. If you have received a decision, a letter or an order, the date on it is the most important fact in your file.

Talk to Gurpreet about your case

These matters turn on dates, disclosure and the exact ground alleged. A consultation establishes what you are facing, what rights you still have, and how long you have to use them.

Book a consultation

Paid consultation · RCIC‑IRB

General information only. This page describes how these processes work in general terms. It is not legal advice and it does not create a consultant–client relationship. Outcomes depend on the facts of the individual case and on law and policy that change.

Statutory references are to the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act and the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations. Representation before the Federal Court must be conducted by a lawyer. Content reviewed November 2026.

Further reading

All articles →